OPEN BORDERS LOBBY PUSHES
NEW AMNESTIES FOR ILLEGAL ALIENS DESPITE
9/11 TRAGEDY, LAY-OFFS, AND A WEAK ECONOMY
The open borders lobby renewed its campaign
for amnesty for millions of illegal aliens, in spite of 9/11,
continuing layoffs, and a weak economy. The Bush Administration
and Democratic Congressional leadership are leading the campaign
with a March 22 target.
Any such amnesty would result in the legalization of millions
of illegal aliens, in addition to current levels of legal immigration
which is running well over one million per year, and illegal
immigration which is adding at least another half million a
year.
If 9/11 didn't teach us enough about the dangers of indulgent
immigration policies and gross non-enforcement of existing laws,
you would think the current downturn in the economy and resulting
unemployment might serve as a wake-up call for Congress and
the Bush Administration. Mass immigration is costly to the American
people on a number of levels.
Yesterday's hype was an alleged "labor shortage."
In a nutshell, we were told that we had more jobs than people,
so we needed to import millions from around the globe. Who believes
that now?, now that so many Americans are struggling to keep
their jobs and healthcare insurance. Yesterday's immigration
policy is the reason we are stuck with providing employment,
health care, education, welfare, and many other benefits for
millions of newcomers. Why are thousands more each day allowed
-- even encouraged -- to come and stay?
"Some people believe that our talks with Mexico have died
in the wake of Sept. 11. I assure you that this is not the case,"
Immigration and Naturalization Service Commissioner James Ziglar
told a crowd of immigration advocates and lawyers at a Washington
forum recently. "We should move forward -- not because
it's in Mexico's interest, but because it's in the United States'
interest. These workers are important to the U.S. economy."
But what about the millions of U.S. unemployed?, BALANCE asks!
Every year, Americans lose $133 billion in wage depression
and job loss as a result of immigration, according to Harvard
Professor George Borjas.
In the decade from 1997-2006, we American taxpayers will have
spent a minimum of $932 billion net (i.e., after subtracting
taxes immigrants pay) to finance mass immigration, according
to a study by Dr. Donald Huddle, Professor Emeritus of Economics
at Rice University.
Some immigrant groups receive more U.S. welfare benefits per
capita than natives do. Research by the Center for Immigration
Studies has revealed that 31 percent of all Mexican immigrant
households use at least one major welfare program (over twice
as much as natives).
And one Congressman, Rep. Chris Cannon (R-UT), has even introduced
a bill, H.R. 1918, which would give low in-state tuition rates
and eligibility for Pell grants and student loans to illegal
alien students, much like the University of California Board
of Regents recently voted to do in California, while out-of-state
citizens would presumably still be forced to pay out-of-state
tuition.
These are all reasons enough to justify pushing hard for a
time-out from current mass immigration while we reassess what
our country can afford and how we can make our policies more
sustainable.
Yet, despite our current economic crises, and despite the
post-9/11 promises to control immigration, the Bush Administration
and the Democratic Congressional leadership are playing election-year
politics by pushing for even more immigration and more benefits
for immigrants!
Here's what BALANCE's contacts on the Hill are telling us:
A new visa-tracking bill will be moving through the Senate
to complement that already passed by the House. Good news at
first glance, BUT some Representatives are already pushing to
attach another 245(i) extension that would provide amnesty for
hundreds of thousands of illegal immigrants, and the bill could
serve as a vehicle for the attachment of a larger amnesty provision,
as well.
AND Bush supports giving food stamps to non-citizen immigrants
[reversing part of the welfare reform legislation enacted in
1996]. With an already suffering economy, do we really want
to admit more people who need to be financially support by our
government?
A guestworker bill is pending in Congress and getting increasing
support. BUT, our sources tell us this is likely to be a de
facto amnesty. AND, in any event, studies show that only a handful
of guestworkers ever return to their native countries. Indeed,
there is no resident quite so permanent as a "temporary"
guestworker. With 11 million illegal aliens already living in
the United States (according to a 2001 study at Northeastern
University), do we need to bring in even more poor, low skilled
workers?
An I.N.S. reform bill is also on the Congressional Agenda,
another potentially good bill which would divide the agency
into two branches: service and enforcement. BUT, unfortunately,
we're expecting to see a 245(i) extension or an amnesty piggy-backed
onto this bill, as well, in case it fails elsewhere.
And the push to give driver's licences to illegal aliens has
intensified across the United States.
WORST... President Bush and Mexican President Vicente Fox
are scheduled to meet again to "discuss" these issues
on March 22 and, our sources tell us, they would like to announce
an amnesty and guestworker program at that time. We must build
momentum before that date to stop the amnesty and guestworker
program.
Two simple steps can change our future -- but we all must
act now. You might be tempted to throw up your hands in frustration
with the whole mess. Don't. Take just a few minutes of your
time, and your support can be pivotal in stopping increasing
overpopulation, environmental degradation, decreased national
security, and greater economic problems.
#1. Ask your Representatives to support Moratorium
Bill H.R. 2712 with an amendment to cap the numbers at 100,000
per year. Instead of calling or writing your Representative
about the myriad of bills and issues floating around in Congress
at the moment, just ask him or her to support one bill: H.R.
2712, the Mass Immigration Reduction Act, which explicitly enacts
a moratorium on most immigration categories and which would
bring current annual numbers down from a million a year to about
300,000.
By signing the enclosed Petition, you will be letting your
Representative know that you not only want to see this bill
passed, but that you want a special amendment to bring the numbers
down to an even more manageable 100,000 per year. H.R. 2712
is a true moratorium bill, and we have got to do everything
we can to show Congress that we want it passed. Please sign
the enclosed Petition and return it to us or directly to your
Representatives immediately.
#2. It is essential to increase our grassroots clout
to overcome the pro-mass immigration special interests. Help
us increase our grassroots clout by giving gift memberships
to BALANCE, and a donation, too, if you can. How much can that
help? A lot more than you think. Every new BALANCE member increases
our political impact and enhances our funding potential. Foundations
and politicians look closely at our numbers to see how much
support BALANCE has -- and to see how seriously we need to be
taken. So, simple gift memberships actually end up being multiplied
several times because they help BALANCE receive larger gifts
from foundations, and because they help us gain even more clout
among our friends in Congress.
Finally, put your completed donation and gift membership form
in the enclosed BRE and mail it to BALANCE today.
And one more thing -- if we are to head off the opposition
before the momentum for an amnesty becomes irresistible, we
must act NOW, and we need your support and gift memberships
NOW to be effective.
P.S. And, in case there is any doubt about the magnitude of
our challenge, consider another recent statement of I.N.S. Commissioner
Ziglar:
"If we could find a way to move a substantial portion
of the current illegal flow from Mexico into legal channels
via some kind of temporary-worker program and combine that with
a new cooperative law enforcement arrangements with Mexico,
we could benefit the U.S. economy, we could substantially reduce
illegal immigra tion."
WANT TO RECEIVE BALANCE E-MAIL ALERTS?
SEND YOUR E-MAIL ADDRESS TO US AT USPOP@US.NET
Population-Environment Balance is a national, non-profit membership
organization dedicated to maintaining the quality of life in the United
States through population stabilization. |